“From a lawsuit to a fair decision: how lawyers from “Kasyanenko and Partners” protected the client’s interests in the case against “Nova Poshta””.
Recently, the public’s attention was captivated by a lawsuit in which the Kasyanenko and Partners law firm defended the interests of its client against a major courier service known as Nova Poshta. The case concerning the recovery of debt for transportation services has attracted considerable attention among the professional community due to its complexity and potential impact on further judicial practice.
A landmark moment in the “Court with New Mail” for our law firm was the accurate study of the details of the contract, which turned out to be key to the formation of a defense strategy. Analysis of evidence and careful monitoring of the legality of claims allowed us to effectively protect the reputation and financial interests of our client.
When “Nova Poshta” filed a lawsuit, the attitude was serious, because the company is known for its extensive distribution network and fierceness in protecting its interests. However, confidence in justice and a detailed analysis of every piece of the evidence base overcame all doubts.
In the role of the “lawyer of Nova poіhta”, flaws were discovered in the company’s position, which led to doubts about the objectivity of their demands for debt collection. The experience and attention of our lawyers forced us to reconsider the grounds of the accusation.
The decision of the court, in this case, could become a precedent that would significantly influence the “judicial practice of Nova poshta”. Thanks to the efforts of our team, we were able to prevent the setting of a potentially dangerous precedent for the business environment.
What the court decided:
The claim of the limited liability company “Nova Poshta” against ________ for the recovery of UAH 78,462.71 shall be dismissed. Collect UAH 8,000.00 from Nova Poshta Limited Liability Company in favor of ____________. expenses for professional legal assistance.
In the course of lively court debates, where unwavering arguments and careful analysis collided, the “Kasyanenko and Partners” law firm once again confirmed its high professional level and won an important victory for its client. Transparency and devotion to the truth are the basis of our daily work, we strive to protect the rights and interests of clients in complex and highly competitive areas such as logistics services.
Three options for resolving the situation in favor of the client can be as follows:
1. Negotiations and Peace Agreement:
Lawyers can enter into negotiations with Nova Poshta in order to reach a settlement agreement that would satisfy the interests of both parties and ensure the settlement of the dispute without further litigation.
2. Judicial protection:
Presentation of all collected evidence in court to refute the position of “New Post” and demonstrate that the supplier fulfilled all obligations according to the contract and that claims for recovery are unfounded.
3. Alternative dispute resolution:
An appeal or mediation to resolve the conflict, possibly with the involvement of an independent third party, which can offer a fair solution acceptable to both parties.
The list of documents for a lawyer to protect the rights and interests of suppliers may include:
- A copy of the original agreement on the provision of services for the organization of transportation was sent between “Nova Poshta” and the courier.
- All express invoices specified in the contract, confirming the fact of the provision of services.
- Financial documents confirming the payment of services by the supplier.
- Correspondence between the supplier and Nova Poshta, may indicate a change in conditions or any other important circumstances.
- Certificates of handover and acceptance of works, which may be offered as an alternative confirmation of the performance of transportation services.
- Written evidence or testimonials from recipients sent, proving that the services were provided properly.
- Claims or responses to them sent between the parties.
- Evidence confirming the possible refusal of the recipients to receive the sent items (if the obligations of the parties depend on this).
- Letters about applying to the Novaya Poshta support service and responses to them.
- Claims and their consideration.
- Legal expertise, conclusions, or other documents generated by experts or consultants.
- Other documents that may be relevant depending on the circumstances of the case.
+380672399388
Court decision
reyestr.court.gov.ua
